What is New vs. Returning Visitors?
“New vs. Returning Visitors” compares first-time users of a website to those who have visited before. This distinction helps marketers understand audience behavior, loyalty, and the effectiveness of acquisition versus retention strategies.
Why New vs. Returning Visitors matters?
Tracking new and returning visitors reveals how well a brand attracts and retains customers. A healthy mix of both signals balanced growth — new visitors expand reach, while returning visitors indicate engagement and loyalty. Shifts in these ratios can highlight issues in customer experience or marketing efficiency.
How New vs. Returning Visitors works?
Analytics tools like Google Analytics or Adobe Analytics use browser cookies or login data to identify whether a visitor is new or returning. A “new” visitor has no prior session history, while a “returning” visitor has interacted with the site before. Marketers often segment performance metrics by visitor type to evaluate which campaigns drive first visits versus repeat engagement.
Example in ecommerce
An online skincare brand notices that 70% of site traffic is from new visitors but conversion rates are higher among returning ones. They launch an email nurture series and a loyalty program to encourage repeat visits and increase conversions from that returning segment. Over time, this helps improve overall customer lifetime value.
Common mix-ups
“Returning visitors” shouldn’t be confused with “repeat customers.” A returning visitor might browse again without buying, while a repeat customer has completed more than one purchase. Similarly, “sessions” differ from “visitors” — one visitor can have multiple sessions.
Best practices
- Track both segments regularly and monitor their ratio over time.
- Use personalized content or retargeting ads to bring back high-value visitors.
- Offer loyalty incentives or email campaigns to convert returning visitors into repeat buyers.
- Optimize onboarding or landing experiences for new visitors to reduce bounce rates.
- Segment marketing analytics (conversion rate, session duration, average order value) by visitor type for deeper insight.
Industry benchmarks
- Typical ecommerce sites see 60–75% new visitors and 25–40% returning visitors.
- Returning visitors often show 2–3x higher conversion rates than new visitors.
- High-performing DTC brands aim for at least 30% returning visitor traffic, indicating strong engagement and retention.
Related terms
You made it all the way down here?
Might as well give us a shot, right? It'll change the way you approach CRO. We promise. In fact, our friend Nate over at Original Grain used element-level revenue data from heatmap to identify high-impact areas of his website to test, resulting in a 17% lift in Revenue per Session while scaling site traffic by 43%. Be like Nate. Try heatmap today.
